Stars explained: * A production of no real merit with failings in all areas. ** A production showing evidence of not enough time or effort, or even talent, and which never breathes any real life into the piece – or a show lumbered with a terrible script. *** A good enjoyable show which might have some small flaws but has largely achieved what it set out to do.**** An excellent show which shows a great deal of work and stage craft with no noticeable or major flaws.***** A four star show which has found that extra bit of magic which lifts theatre to another plane.
Half stars fall between the ratings

Delightful play, pity about the name

The Odd Couple (Female Version)

Billesley Players

The Old Rep, Birmingham

****

IT is the play with just about the ugliest, clumsiest name on the circuit, but Iain Neville's production ensures that it overcomes its built-in bracketed drawback with aplomb.

Even so, it is hard to believe that a playwright as felicitous as Neil Simon could not have thought of a title that matched his talent and reputation, instead of treating the original male version as a convenient hook on which to hang another story of ill-assorted apartment-sharers.

That said, this is an account that brims with well-furnished fun. The sloppy Olive and the meticulous Florence have been thrown together when Florence's marriage has fallen apart after 14 years. As we watch their partnership develop, we have no qualms about enjoying its chuckle-filled fruits. For us simple theatregoers, this was a marital disaster made in heaven.

Florence – or Flo – is the hygienic, fussy fanatic, though no one seeing her pick up those littering crisps on the first night, not on the same day that they had been dropped because the curtain had also dropped in the meantime, would have had cause to suspect this, had the unscripted tidying been seen in isolation.

But this account by Sheila Parkes is a delight of disciplined orderliness – spiced at one point by her extraordinary attempt to unblock Flo's ears and only straining her throat for her trouble.

INNOCENT IMPISHNESS

Gemma Harris, as Olive, is a joy of innocent impishness beneath a wondrously curly wig which at times she did not seem to trust to remain in place. Not that this was allowed to get in the way of a lovely performance as the woman required against her will to keep her hormones in check in the absence of any male company.  

She has a way of puffing her cheeks as part of a wild, wide-eyed grin that is irresistibly infectious.

This is a splendid pairing and it thrives on its responsibilities as the centrepiece of the plot – but it does have amusing support all round, particularly from Leon Salter and Edward Fellows in their version of two amiable Spaniards who are inadvertently at war with the English language.

Then there are Claire Davies (Silvie), Patricia Hands (Renée), Samantha Broome (Vera, the blonde who has been known to spend 20 minutes talking to a security guard before discovering he was a statue) and Jo Wall (Mickey, the New York cop who appears to spend her off-duty life in uniform as she joins the others in an eternal board game). All make a pleasing contribution, with Claire Davies having a particularly joyful exit line.

This is a happy production by a talented group. It is a shame that its two-day run is over before the world at large realises it has started, but those patrons alert to its circumscribing are very well rewarded, To 11.06.11.

John Slim 

Home Reviews A-Z Reviews by affiliate