trio in boat

Pictures: Manuel Harlan  

The Shark is Broken

Birmingham Rep

*****

When Ian Shaw and Joseph Nixon’s short play The Shark is Broken first appeared at the Edinburgh Fringe in 2019, neither writer really believed it would appeal to an audience beyond a few die-hard fans of the 1975 blockbuster movie, Jaws. How wrong they were.

Six years on and several sell out tours later, including a season on Broadway, the show has huge box office bite and brought a packed out crowd in Birmingham to its feet on it’s opening night of its current journey.

Box Office appeal is of course what every producer dreams of. A little easier for musicals but harder for straight plays - especially new ones. Stage versions of TV shows and classic movies seem to do well, reintroducing an audience with characters and storylines they already know and love. Jaws fits firmly into that bracket. The millions of teenagers who queued round the block to see the film all those 50 years ago, myself included, are now in their early 60’s - the perfect theatre going demographic who would jump at the chance to reignite some of those teenage memories.

The premise is simple but engaging. The three lead actors on the movie, Roy Scheider, Richard Dreyfuss and Robert Shaw are waiting for their scenes to be shot onboard the on set fishing boat. Gaps between scenes are long, largely due to problems with the mechanical shark (famously nicknamed Bruce). Time waiting is spent telling stories, drinking whisky, bickering and playing games. Insecurities and self-doubt creep in as the booze takes hold and the feeling of cooped up claustrophobia begins to ramp up the stress.

 

still in the boat

These are three very different chararcters with contrasting backgrounds and ways of living. Not three friends of similar outlook choosing to be there, but three disparate individuals forced to be together as hired actors on a project. Sparks are inevitably going to fly and the breaking point is never far away.

Aside from the remarkable physical resemblance of the three actors to Scheider, Dreyfuss and Shaw, the chemistry between them is superbly replicated. Mannerisms, speech patterns, laughter and general physicality are captured beautifully to a point where it’s almost like watching the originals

Physical resemblance is perhaps the easiest for Ian Shaw to achieve, being the son of Robert Shaw - the wily, rough diamond shark hunter Quint in the movie. Ian Shaw, now the same age as his dad was when he did the film, captures the sheer charisma and bravado of his father whilst not ignoring or denying the obvious demons in his life.

It’s an intensely personal and connected performance that gives a fascinating insight into the man’s take on life. As good an actor as Robert Shaw was, he was also something of a reluctant one, not fully believing that acting was a job for real men and taking every opportunity to rib other actors who took themselves and their work too seriously. In this instance, Richard Dreyfuss (Ashley Margolis) gets put in his place whenever he tries to elevate his celebrity status.

Margolis fizzes with energy as Richard Dreyfuss, the young upstart actor hoping this movie will be the start of a glittering career. Dreyfuss, a fast talking, wise cracking new breed of actor is the direct opposite of his older shipmates and the verbal clashes are played out beautifully by the three actors here. Again, physicality is perfectly observed by Margolis - the laugh, the quizzical glances and the mix of euphoria and dejection associated with Dreyfuss are spot on throughout.

boat

Making up the trio is Roy Scheider, played with studious attention to detail by Dan Fredenburgh. Scheider is reflected as the sensible one, the peacemaker when fireworks between Shaw and Dreyfuss go off.

Top notch performances aside, a further strength in what is essentially a series of conversations onboard a boat, lies in the writing. Some of the lines are actually quotes recalled by Ian Shaw which give obvious added resonance. There are some wonderful references too about film sequels and Speilberg’s later output which drew appreciative in on the joke laughter from a totally engaged audience.

Duncan Henderson’s set design alongside an atmospheric lighting design by Jon Clark frames the action simply but with real authenticity. The fishing boat dominates the stage whilst back projection shows the ocean, complete with swooping sea birds, sunrises and storms. Calmness amongst the delays happening on the set and the tension building onboard.

There could be an argument for an interval - venues would certainly like the bar income – but the running time of around 90 minutes for a one act play seems about right

A superbly crafted piece of theatre with universal appeal. Get your teeth into it … while you can. The shark will be broken to 10-05-25.

Tom Roberts

06-05-25 

Index page Rep Reviews A-Z Reviews by Theatre